Feature
John Elliott On School Academies
About this feature
In this Community Chest interview, guest John Elliott discusses the structure and impact of school academies. He examines the lack of public accountability inherent in private sponsorship and the absence of research evidence proving that academies improve standards. The recording also covers the controversy surrounding the proposed Hartsee's Academy in Norwich.
In this interview from the programme Community Chest, guest John Elliott discusses the structure and impact of school academies. He defines them as state-funded independent schools controlled by private sponsors, noting that sponsors were previously required to raise at least two million pounds. Elliott highlights concerns regarding a lack of public accountability since trustees, rather than local authorities, run these schools. He also mentions research from Edinburgh University suggesting little curriculum innovation and argues there is no unambiguous research evidence that academies improve standards, despite government claims. The discussion also touches upon the controversy surrounding the proposed Hartsee's Academy in Norwich, where Elliott serves as a community governor.
Topics
- The definition and funding structure of school academies
- Public accountability and the role of private sponsors
- The controversy surrounding the proposed Hartsee's Academy in Norwich
- Academy school standards and evidence
Participants
- Dominik
- John Elliott
- Thordis Fredriksson
- Reid Dixon
- John
Listen · selected clips
No clips have been selected for this feature yet.
Passages from the recording
Text from the recording. These passages are not linked to a playable clip.
In other words, they are lacking in what you might call public accountability. So you've got there. I mean, the main objection is that large sums of public money, of the taxpayers' money, is being spent on schools, which are not really a
The the big debate that is going on right now. Well, I should explain something about the Hartsee situation, my involvement in it, because I am a community governor at Hartsee, so I'm speaking really as a community governor rather than an academic at UEA.
Without any evidence, I mean, the other thing is there is no unambiguous research evidence that academies improve standards. Although the government would make a counterclaim and says there is, but actually, when you look at the evidence.